Team Hub

AFC South

Indianapolis Colts

Team OVR
80

Team Snapshot

The Indianapolis Colts enter 2026-2027 as a franchise under pressure: after squandering an 8-2 start to finish 8-9 and miss the playoffs for a fifth straight season, they retained head coach Shane Steichen and GM Chris Ballard for a make-or-break campaign built around a healthy Daniel Jones, workhorse RB Jonathan Taylor, and a retooled defense.

Franchise Difficulty

4/5 ยท Hard

How hard this franchise is to run well: where the team stands, what the roster gives you, what the cap allows, and what you hold in the draft.

A dead-last quarterback room headlined by a 71-overall Daniel Jones, bottom-five starters at right tackle, strong safety, Will linebacker, and left guard, combined with a twilight Charvarius Ward needing a succession plan and committed cap jumping to $293.0M next season, leave almost no margin for error despite the massive current cap surplus.

Star Players

Scheme Fit

The schemes this team is set to run in-game, and how its roster grades in them.

  • West Coast Power RunoffensivePassable
  • Tampa 2defensivePassable

Build the playbook for this roster.

Playbook Genius ranks the schemes that fit the Indianapolis Colts and builds a playbook and call sheet around them.

Salary Cap

Cap Room
$86.9M

Rank #1 of 32

Dead Money
$15.0M

Rank #22 of 32

Rollover
$1.9M

Rank #26 of 32

Next-Year Cap Room
$24.8M

Rank #18 of 32

The Colts hold the most cap room in the league at $86.9M, giving them immediate power to reshape the roster, but commitments balloon to $293.0M next season so the spending window is narrow.

25 contracts expiring

Depth Chart

Madden Tools Analysis

Nine starting spots have weak depth behind the starter.

Biggest gaps behind a starter

  • HB
  • WR
  • LT
  • LG
  • RT
Plus 4 more on the full depth chart

Draft Capital

Upcoming Draft
10
First-Rounders
2
Next Three Drafts
25
R10
R21
R32
R43
R52
R61
R71

Ten picks this cycle including two first-rounders and an imported haul of acquired selections gives the Colts genuine rebuild fuel, though a forfeited first-rounder to the Jets is a meaningful cost.

  • Acquired: Round 7 from Bills, this draft
  • Acquired: Round 5 from Chiefs, this draft
  • Acquired: Round 4 from Chiefs, this draft
  • Acquired: Round 4 from 49ers, this draft
  • Acquired: Round 6 from Ravens, this draft
  • Acquired: Round 5 from Seahawks, next draft
  • Acquired: Round 3 from Seahawks, this draft
  • Traded away: Round 6 to Bills, this draft
  • Traded away: Round 7 to Chiefs, this draft
  • Traded away: Round 1 to Jets, this draft

Team Ratings

The roster's clearest strength is its cornerback group anchored by an 88-overall and an 86-overall starter, while quarterback is the most glaring weakness with the starter coming in at just 71 overall and ranking last leaguewide.

Overall
76
Offense
75
Defense
76

Strengths

  • C
  • CB
  • HB
  • FS

Weak spots

  • LG
  • MIKE
  • QB
  • REDGE
  • RT

Offense

QBWRTEOLHB/FB

Defense

DTEDGELBCBS

Special teams

Roster Needs

  • LGhigh

    Jalen Farmer (71 overall) starts at left guard but ranks 29th among starters leaguewide, making an upgrade at this spot a priority.

  • MIKEhigh

    Akeem Davis-Gaither (75 overall) is the starter but ranks 29th at the position, and the depth behind him offers little assurance.

  • QBhigh

    Daniel Jones (71 overall) leads a room that ranks dead last among starters leaguewide, making quarterback the single most urgent need on the roster.

  • REDGEhigh

    JT Tuimoloau (74 overall) starts but ranks 28th leaguewide, and the depth behind him is thin relative to the rest of the league.

  • RThigh

    Jalen Travis (70 overall) holds the starting job but ranks last leaguewide at right tackle, making the right side of the line a glaring vulnerability.

  • SShigh

    A.J. Haulcy (74 overall) starts at strong safety but the position ranks 31st leaguewide, with depth that ranks near the very bottom of the league.

  • WILLhigh

    Bryce Boettcher (69 overall) starts but ranks dead last among Will linebackers leaguewide, exposing a significant weakness at the second level.

  • WRmedium

    Alec Pierce leads a receiver room that ranks 22nd at the starter level but near the bottom of the league in overall depth, making additions here important.

Cut Candidates

5-Year Outlook

The Colts are built around a handful of genuine stars, most notably Jonathan Taylor and a strong cornerback tandem in Sauce Gardner and Charvarius Ward Sr, but the roster has critical structural holes that limit how far those stars can carry the team right now. The quarterback situation is the most pressing concern, as Daniel Jones provides league-worst starter value and no developmental option behind him has yet distinguished himself. The offensive line is a patchwork outside of Bernhard Raimann, with right tackle and left guard both ranking among the worst starting positions in the league. On defense, the linebacker corps is similarly exposed at both Mike and Will. The young core of Tyler Warren and Tanor Bortolini gives the team legitimate pieces to build around at center and tight end, and A.J. Haulcy and JT Tuimoloau offer developmental upside at safety and edge. Ward Sr is a productive starter today but is entering the later stage of his career, so the team must plan for life beyond him at corner. With $86.9M in cap room ranking first in the league this season, the Colts have the financial firepower to accelerate a rebuild, but cap committed next season rises sharply to $293.0M, narrowing the window to act aggressively.

5-Year Plan

  1. Year 1Spend the room, fix the foundation

    • Use the league-leading $86.9M in cap space to sign a legitimate starting quarterback and at least one right tackle upgrade in free agency, targeting the team's two dead-last positional rankings.
    • Release Laquon Treadwell, D.J. Montgomery, Luke Tenuta, Charlie Heck, and Will Mallory to clear roughly $4.0M in additional space and clean dead roster spots ahead of acquisitions.
    • Let Tanor Bortolini and Tyler Warren settle into their starting roles and accumulate developmental reps as the long-term offensive core.
  2. Year 2Develop the young core, shore up the linebackers

    • Prioritize getting Tyler Warren (Superstar dev) and Tanor Bortolini (Star dev) into featured roles so their traits can accelerate progression toward their ceilings.
    • Address the Will and Mike linebacker spots, which ranked last and 29th in the league respectively, by targeting upgrades through the 10 picks available this draft cycle, including two first-rounders.
    • Evaluate CJ Allen and JT Tuimoloau as internal candidates for bigger roles as their age and dev traits suggest room to grow.
  3. Year 3Build the edge, plan for the corner

    • Develop JT Tuimoloau (23, Star) and George Gumbs Jr. (23, Normal) into legitimate contributors at REDGE so the position no longer ranks near the bottom of the league.
    • Begin succession planning at cornerback given that Charvarius Ward Sr is entering the later stage of his career, targeting a developmental corner to eventually step in opposite Sauce Gardner.
    • With next-year cap committed at $293.0M and $24.8M projected in room two seasons out, prioritize contract extensions for Tyler Warren and Tanor Bortolini before the market sets their price.
  4. Year 4Contend around the settled core

    • With Tyler Warren and Tanor Bortolini entering their prime years under contract, build the passing game around them and an established starting quarterback.
    • Reload the linebacker depth using the three-year draft capital total of 25 picks accumulated since the rebuild began, focusing on players with higher dev traits.
    • Evaluate Jonathan Taylor's contract situation and determine whether he remains the centerpiece of the backfield or whether Seth McGowan or DJ Giddens can absorb a larger share of the load.
  5. Year 5Make a championship push

    • With cap committed dropping to $112.9M three seasons from now, use the financial flexibility to make a targeted move for a proven pass rusher or defensive playmaker to complement the core.
    • Establish A.J. Haulcy (Star dev) as a fully developed safety starter, completing the rebuild of a secondary that ranked 31st at strong safety in season one.
    • Assess the quarterback situation honestly and either extend the starter signed in season one or use remaining draft capital to find the long-term answer under center.

Young core

Full Roster

60 players
PlayerPosOVRDev
Age 27HB93X Factor development
Age 25CB88Superstar development
Age 28LT86Star development
Age 30CB86Superstar development
Age 26WR84Star development
Age 27K84Normal development
Age 24C83Star development
Age 31P83Star development
Age 32DT83Star development
Age 28FS82Star development
Age 24TE81Superstar development
Age 25LEDGE80Star development

Franchise History

The Colts were founded in 1953 in Baltimore, when a group led by Carroll Rosenbloom was awarded the assets of the defunct Dallas Texans. Under coach Weeb Ewbank and quarterback Johnny Unitas (signed 1956), the Colts rose fast, beating the New York Giants 23-17 on December 28, 1958, in the first sudden-death overtime championship, "The Greatest Game Ever Played." They repeated as NFL champions in 1959 and won another NFL title in 1968. After joining the AFC in the merger, they won Super Bowl V after the 1970 season, defeating Dallas 16-13 on Jim O'Brien's late field goal. After the 1972 season the franchise was sold to Robert Irsay, and in March 1984 Irsay relocated the team to Indianapolis in the infamous "Mayflower Midnight" move. The Peyton Manning era began with the No. 1 overall pick in 1998 and became the greatest stretch in franchise history: 11 playoff appearances, an NFL-record seven straight 12-win seasons (2003-09), and, under coach Tony Dungy, a Super Bowl XLI win after the 2006 season, 29-17 over the Chicago Bears. Manning missed 2011 with neck surgery, and the team drafted Andrew Luck first overall in 2012. Luck led a division-title revival before injuries forced his shocking 2019 retirement. The recent era has been defined by quarterback instability and a playoff drought dating to 2020.

Notable figures

  • Johnny Unitas ยท Quarterback (1956-1972)

    "The Golden Arm"; three-time MVP, led the 1958, 1959 and 1968 title teams and Super Bowl V; widely regarded as the prototype of the modern QB.

    Photo: Malcolm W. Emmons, public domain (Wikimedia Commons)

  • Peyton Manning ยท Quarterback (1998-2010)

    Five-time NFL MVP (four with Indy), Super Bowl XLI champion, franchise leader in passing yards (54,828) and passing TDs (399).

    Photo: U.S. Navy (Chief Photographer's Mate Don Bray), public domain (Wikimedia Commons)

  • Marvin Harrison ยท Wide receiver (1996-2008)

    Hall of Famer; franchise leader in receptions (1,102), receiving yards (14,580) and receiving TDs (128); Manning's top target.

    Photo: Djmunden, CC BY-SA 3.0 (Wikimedia Commons)

  • Reggie Wayne ยท Wide receiver (2001-2014)

    Six-time Pro Bowler, Super Bowl XLI champion, No. 2 in franchise receiving yards (14,345) and franchise leader in games played (211); now the Colts' WR coach.

    Photo: Jeffrey Beall, CC BY-SA 3.0 (Wikimedia Commons)

  • Edgerrin James ยท Running back (1999-2005)

    Hall of Famer; franchise's all-time leading rusher (9,226 yards); 1999 Offensive Rookie of the Year, two-time rushing champ.

    Photo: John Martinez Pavliga, CC BY 2.0 (Wikimedia Commons)

  • Tony Dungy ยท Head coach (2002-2008)

    Winningest coach in franchise history; led the Super Bowl XLI title; first Black head coach to win a Super Bowl; Hall of Famer.

    Photo: U.S. Navy (PM Airman William J. Davis), public domain (Wikimedia Commons)

  • Dwight Freeney ยท Defensive end (2002-2012)

    Seven-time Pro Bowler famed for his spin move; 125.5 career sacks; Super Bowl XLI champion.

    Photo: Jeffrey Beall, CC BY-SA 3.0 (Wikimedia Commons)

  • Robert Mathis ยท Defensive end/linebacker (2003-2016)

    Franchise's all-time sack leader (123) and forced-fumble leader (54); five-time Pro Bowler; Super Bowl XLI champion.

    Photo: Jeffrey Beall, CC BY 4.0 (Wikimedia Commons)

  • Jonathan Taylor ยท Running back (2020-present)

    Franchise's all-time rushing-TD leader (69) and single-season rushing record holder (1,811 in 2021); the current offensive engine.

    Photo: All-Pro Reels, CC BY-SA 2.0 (Wikimedia Commons)

Record book

  • Passing yardsPeyton Manning (54,828)
  • Passing TDsPeyton Manning (399)
  • Rushing yardsEdgerrin James (9,226)
  • Receiving yardsMarvin Harrison (14,580)
  • ReceptionsMarvin Harrison (1,102)
  • SacksRobert Mathis (123 (2003-2016))
  • InterceptionsBobby Boyd (57 (1960-1968))
  • PointsAdam Vinatieri (1,515 (2006-2019))

Team Tips

Playing As

Win on the ground and control tempo. Steichen's offense revolves around Jonathan Taylor, who led the league in total touchdowns (20), rushing touchdowns (18) and carries (323) in 2025, running behind a strong offensive line. Complement the run with play-action and Daniel Jones's efficiency (third-best yards per attempt at 8.1, fourth-best completion percentage at 68%, sixth-best passer rating at 100.2 in 2025). Use deep threat Alec Pierce, who led the NFL in yards per catch (21.3), to stretch the field.

Playing Against

Load the box, make Jones win from the pocket, and pressure him, his late-season injury and the offense's collapse (they lost every game after the Week 11 bye) exposed problems closing games. The defense finished No. 21 in scoring (24.2 ppg allowed) and is young and unproven, with potentially as many as five first- or second-year starters, so test rookie starters and target a secondary dependent on the health of Sauce Gardner and Charvarius Ward.

Coaching ยท Shane Steichen

Head coach entering his fourth season (2026-2027), confirmed returning by owner/CEO Carlie Irsay-Gordon and GM Chris Ballard. An offensive-minded play-caller who developed Justin Herbert and Jalen Hurts before Indianapolis, he enters 25-26 with no playoff appearances, on multiple analysts' "hot seat" lists, and tasked with fixing the late-season and late-game collapses.

Photo: All-Pro Reels, CC BY-SA 2.0 (Wikimedia Commons)

Coming soon

  • Playbook Matches
  • Key Plays & Audibles

Upgrade to Team Hub Rookie

  • Salary cap breakdown
  • Depth chart analysis
  • Roster needs & scheme fit
  • Cut candidates & 5-year outlook
  • Full sortable roster
Upgrade to Team Hub Rookie